Who’s the highest-rated quarterback in this year’s game? Did anyone make the 99 Club? Who’s the best backup QB? Check out Boardroom’s full Madden 23 QB ratings rundown below.
Tom Brady made his debut in EA Sports’ Madden franchise with Madden 01, which was released 22 years ago. He was rated at a 57 as a rookie, and that number actually dropped even further down to 51 at the launch of Madden 02.
That was just before the start of the season in which he won his first Super Bowl with the New England Patriots. Since then, he’s checked in with a perfect 99 overall in five different Madden editions at time of launch — and this time around, he’s once again atop the QB heap with a 97 in this year’s game, one point ahead of his closest competitor.
With that in mind, how does the rest of the virtual quarterback pecking order shake out? Check out Boardroom’s Madden 23 QB ratings overview below.
Subscribe for the biggest stories in the business of sports and entertainment, daily.
Madden QB Ratings
Ratings updated as of Madden 23’s official launch on Aug. 19.
1. Tom Brady (Buccaneers)
- Overall: 97
- General: 82
- Passing: 93
- Archetype: Field General
- Click here to read Boardroom’s deep dive on Tom Brady in Madden 23.
2. Aaron Rodgers (Packers)
- Overall: 96
- General: 84
- Passing: 94
- Archetype: Field General
- Click here to read Boardroom’s deep dive on Aaron Rodgers in Madden 23.
3. Patrick Mahomes (Chiefs)
- Overall: 95
- General: 87
- Passing: 94
- Archetype: Improviser
4. Josh Allen (Bills)
- Overall: 92
- General:
- Passing:
- Archetype: Improviser
- Click here to read Boardroom’s deep dive on Josh Allen in Madden 23.
5. Joe Burrow (Bengals)
- Overall: 90
- General: 85
- Passing: 90
- Archetype: Field General
- Click here to read Boardroom’s deep dive on Joe Burrow in Madden 23.
6. Dak Prescott (Cowboys)
- Overall: 89
- General: 86
- Passing: 91
- Archetype: Improviser
- Click here to read Boardroom’s deep dive on Dak Prescott in Madden 23.
7. Justin Herbert (Chargers)
- Overall: 88
- General: 85
- Passing: 90
- Archetype: Field General
t-8. Lamar Jackson (Ravens)
- Overall: 87
- General: 89
- Passing: 89
- Archetype: Scrambler
- Click here to read Boardroom’s deep dive on Lamar Jackson in Madden 23.
t-8. Russell Wilson (Broncos)
- Overall: 87
- General: 87
- Passing: 91
- Archetype: Improviser
10. Matthew Stafford (Rams)
- Overall: 85
- General: 80
- Passing: 87
- Archetype: Field General
t-11. Deshaun Watson (Browns)
- Overall: 84
- General: 85
- Passing: 89
- Archetype: Scrambler
t-11. Kyler Murray (Cardinals)
- Overall: 84
- General: 82
- Passing: 87
- Archetype: Improviser
- Click here to read Boardroom’s deep dive on Kyler Murray in Madden 23.
t-13. Derek Carr (Raiders)
- Overall: 83
- General: 82
- Passing: 88
- Archetype: Field General
t-13. Ryan Tannehill (Titans)
- Overall: 83
- General: 84
- Passing: 88
- Archetype: Field General
Subscribe for the biggest stories in the business of sports and entertainment, daily.
15. Matt Ryan (Colts)
- Overall: 81
- General: 76
- Passing: 87
- Archetype: Field General
16. Kirk Cousins (Vikings)
- Overall: 80
- General: 76
- Passing: 89
- Archetype: Field General
17. Mac Jones (Patriots)
- Overall: 78
- General: 81
- Passing: 85
- Archetype: Field General
- Click here to read Boardroom’s deep dive on Mac Jones in Madden 23.
t-18. Baker Mayfield (Panthers)
- Overall: 77
- General: 81
- Passing: 86
- Archetype: Improviser
t-18. Jimmy Garoppolo (49ers)
- Overall: 77
- General: 76
- Passing: 85
- Archetype: Field General
t-20. Jameis Winston (Saints)
- Overall: 76
- General: 80
- Passing: 84
- Archetype: Improviser
t-20. Trevor Lawrence (Jaguars)
- Overall: 76
- General: 84
- Passing: 84
- Archetype: Scrambler
Subscribe for the biggest stories in the business of sports and entertainment, daily.
